OpenAI, the U.S.-based artificial intelligence company renowned for developing ChatGPT, has contested the jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court in a copyright infringement lawsuit filed by Indian news agency Asian News International (ANI). The legal dispute centers on allegations that OpenAI utilized ANI’s content without authorization to train its AI models.
Jurisdictional Objections Raised by OpenAI
In a recent submission to the Delhi High Court, OpenAI asserted that it lacks any physical presence or permanent establishment in India, emphasizing that its operations and servers are based in the United States. Consequently, the company argued that the Indian court does not possess the jurisdiction to adjudicate the matter. OpenAI further contended that complying with ANI’s demand to remove its data from ChatGPT’s training modules would conflict with its legal obligations under U.S. law, which mandate the preservation of such data during ongoing litigation.
Background of the Legal Dispute
ANI initiated legal proceedings against OpenAI in November 2024, alleging that the AI firm had used its published content without permission to train ChatGPT. The news agency accused OpenAI of not only infringing upon its copyrights but also of attributing fabricated news stories to ANI. In response, during a November hearing, OpenAI assured the court that it would cease using ANI’s content in future AI model training. However, ANI maintained that its published works remained stored in ChatGPT’s servers and insisted on their deletion.
OpenAI’s Defense and Legal Position
OpenAI has consistently denied any copyright infringement, asserting that its AI models are trained using publicly available data in a manner protected by fair use and related legal principles. The company highlighted its existing licensing agreements with reputable news organizations, such as The Financial Times and The Associated Press, for the use of copyrighted content. OpenAI emphasized that it is engaged in partnerships with many news organizations globally and is exploring more such opportunities, including in India.
ANI’s Allegations and Legal Demands
ANI has accused OpenAI of refusing to obtain a lawful license or permission to use its original works. The news agency is seeking damages amounting to ₹2 crore and has requested a decree of mandatory and permanent injunction against OpenAI. ANI’s legal filing also expressed concerns about fabricated news stories being attributed to the publication by ChatGPT, which could potentially harm its reputation.
Upcoming Court Proceedings
The Delhi High Court has scheduled the next hearing for this case on January 28, 2025. The court is expected to deliberate on the jurisdictional challenges raised by OpenAI and assess the merits of ANI’s allegations. This case marks a significant legal confrontation between a major AI company and a news organization in India, potentially setting a precedent for future disputes involving artificial intelligence and copyright laws.
Implications for AI and Copyright Law
This legal battle underscores the complex intersection of artificial intelligence, copyright law, and international jurisdiction. As AI models increasingly rely on vast amounts of data, including copyrighted material, to enhance their capabilities, questions arise regarding the legality and ethics of such practices. The outcome of this case could have far-reaching implications for AI developers and content creators, potentially influencing how AI models are trained and how intellectual property rights are protected in the digital age.
As the case progresses, it will be closely monitored by stakeholders in the technology and media sectors, as well as legal experts, given its potential to shape the future framework governing AI and content usage.
Our dedicated team gathers information from all the reliable sources to make the law accessible and understandable for everyone. We provide the latest legal news stories from across the country, delivered straight to you.